Thursday, May 22, 2014

Babette's Feast Panel Paper-Casey Tulley-Religion and Food

Films can often be classified as being from more than just a single genre.  Babette’s Feast is one of those movies.  While food obviously plays a rather important and outward role in the film, it can be seen that religion and religious overtones are ever present throughout the film.  The ways in which the characters behave and make decisions, how they interact with other characters, especially males, and even some of the meals they eat can be seen coming directly from a specific religious upbringing. Babette’s Feast is a great example of how food in film can be used in conjunction with other overarching characteristics to compliment and better convey the story and overall message.
The most overt sign that Babette’s Feast is a religious movie is that two of the main characters, Philippa and Martine, are the daughters of a man who was essentially the founder of a group of Christians who dedicated themselves to plain and simple lives, even in the food that they eat.  In the opening scene the sisters are shown delivering meals to some of the villagers. The simple pots are opened to reveal a basic broth, something that would be nourishing but adherent to the values their strict Christian father instilled in the community. The influence of both food and religion are further seen early in the movie as Babette is first introduced serving tea to a group of religious elders who are meeting and singing hymns. Babette is charged with preparing meals for the sisters and for the community for the sisters to pass out. Though she is very good at what she does she yearns for making more than the cod stew and bread.
Food and religion again come back in to play when it is revealed that Babette has won the lottery back home in France. With the extra money she decides to make a full French meal to be served at the village’s major celebration. Being that she is a servant to Martine and Philippa she must get their consent beforehand. They wanted to have a modest dinner, in keeping with how their group usually does everything, but eventually agree to let Babette cook a French feast for the people, using her winnings. As the sisters see the ingredients Babette is bringing in for the feast they begin to change their minds and worry that a meal of such magnitude will corrupt the pious people who will be attending. They tell the rest of the group to be cautious and all agree to attend the feast but to focus on something other than the food, intending to try not to taste it. A major contrast is shown at this point in the movie as the group arrives for a magnificent French feast in very drab clothing.
The major turning point in the movie, from a religious standpoint, involves the celebration meal. General Lowenhielm, a one-time suitor of Martine has returned to be with his aunt, one of the members of the religious sect. As he does not prescribe to the same religious convictions as the group he is attending with the general is enamored with the feast and begins recounting a tale of the best chef in Paris and the meals she would make. The general’s story mixed with the party wine helps to open up the conversation among party goers. The once stoic group of pious folks begins to reconcile with each other for past transgressions. The group is not changed so much in the foundations of their belief but it seems that the meal has opened the sect up to a bit more inclusion and understanding.

It is easy to see with a less than analytic eye that Babette’s Feast combines both religion and food to create the overall story. It is the blending of the two together that is so well done.  The way in which meals are prepared and the meals themselves are obviously passed down from the original leader of the sect in a very specifically religious way. Babette’s Feast is, therefore, a wonderful example of using food, in combination with other elements, to create a great story and entertaining movie.

12 comments:

  1. Now that you've watched it again, do you still think it's a religious film? I know we discussed it a bit further in class, but I wasn't sure if you still stood by that.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Personally, I do. I can definitely understand how people would see it as less religious as a whole. For me, though, I still see it as a movie based in religion, using food as a supporter. Much of the Christian stories of the Bible take place at a feast, meal, or party, and I believe this was telling a story in many of the same ways.

      Delete
    2. I imagine I'm the odd duck who sees this more as just a regular film with a heavy emphasis on both food and religion, and less as a food film or a religious film. I could see the plot interchanging soccer in for food or for religion and the climax being about how Babbete spends all her lotto winnings on taking them to a big game or something.

      Delete
    3. I saw this movie, Babette's Feast, as a religious film with an emphasis on food. Through out the entire film religion was the primary topic. However food and cooking were displayed through out the movie as well, especially towards the end. None the less I saw this as a religious film because the topic always came back to religion and every thing that the characters did and stood for was based off of their religion.

      Delete
    4. I didn't think it was a religious film, but can see how many of the elements can been seen in this film.

      Delete
  2. I saw so many religious parables in this movie. The fact that the main location was an island set apart from the mainland was a huge for me personally. So many "religious" people believe they must set them selves apart from others through their practices or beliefs. In reality it is not about an outward action that moves us closer in our relationship to God but an inward action of accepting what God has done for us. I thought Babette servant attitude, and her generosity was the perfect example of an inward action and example of God's love versus the piety of the people that lived on this island.

    ReplyDelete
  3. It's definitely about religion, or spirituality, but it's not proselytizing for a particular religious belief. In other words, after watching The Greatest Story Ever Told we know exactly what religious perspective the film advocates. With Babette, we might come away thinking about how religion fits in our lives, but probably don't come away thinking we should live on a remote island following the ways of the Founder.
    Further, the focus of the film is Babette, the artist who we might say makes the diner's religious beliefs possible again.

    As whether this is a soccer film or not or could be. I guess it could be, but it's emphatically not. It's about how cuilinary art (or any Art) can communicate to the spirit through the flesh. You can say something like that about sport, but I don't see how this looks remote like this film.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. This is kind of my take away from it as well. I think the religious angle is an intriguing component, but I think that focusing too much on that part of it is to miss the point.

      It's not as though there is an explicitly Christ-like figure for us to glom on to (feel free to replace Christ with the messiah of your choosing). Instead, it's more about the act of artistic creation and how that act can demonstrably improves the lives of those who consume it.

      Delete
  4. I am with Forrest on this one. It seems to me that the main focus is the importance of tradition versus the problems with stagnation. Religion was more of a setting than a focus. It was more of a backdrop for some of the more important characters anyway. The two suitors (the general and the opera singer) were not necessarily religious and Babette herself was an artist.

    To be fair: food and art can be a religious experience (or at least something spiritual) Babette's feast is the culmination of the two but it's more about the gift she is giving to the community in allowing them to come back together and the gift she is giving herself to be able to feel alive and like an artist again than anything else. In my opinion

    ReplyDelete
  5. I see that you have valid points in each comment. I was thinking that the feast was a way to say thank you for giving her a place to call home, a place to feel accepted. She lost her husband and son because of war. The Opera singer offered her solace with the two sisters. Her talents was the art of cooking and with the lottery winnings she was able to offer a gift of thanks to the sisters. The sisters had no idea of her talents nor did they know much about her but in the end they found that they didn't want to lose her. She is a part of their family.

    ReplyDelete
  6. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I would say that this film is somewhat a religious film. Although, I would not classify it as a religious film, but more say that it has a large amount of religious aspects. There are many films that wouldn't be classified as a religious film persay, but do have religious elements to them. I agree with Blue about her reasoning for putting on the feast and using her 10,000 for the feast. The sisters helped her when she had nothing or no one, and now she could finally "say thank you" back.

    ReplyDelete